Why Would Someone Choose a Mutual Fund Over a Stock? (2024)

Investing can be complicated and overwhelming. There are many different investment options including stocks, bonds, real estate and money market accounts. If you invest on your own, it's up to you to pick your investments, monitor their performance, and modify your investment strategy over time.

Another option for investors is to partner with a mutual fund. You can still build wealth through investing, but a mutual fund helps make investment decisions for you. If you're curious why some investors choose to invest with a mutual fund instead of picking their own stocks, read on to learn some common advantages of mutual funds.

Key Takeaways

  • Mutual funds pool money together from a group of investors and invest that capital into different securities.
  • Each mutual fund has a goal that defines its risk profile, investing objective, and overall strategy.
  • Mutual funds offer diversified holdings in many different industries or types of securities.
  • Investing in a mutual fund is a good way to avoid some of the complicated decision-making involved in investing in stocks.
  • Though mutual funds still charge manage fees, the cost of trading is spread over all mutual fund investors, thereby lowering the cost per individual.

Mutual Funds vs. Stocks

  • Mutual funds offer an individual investor exposure to many stocks, not a few.
  • The stocks in the fund are selected and managed by professional portfolio managers who do all the work of buying and selling with the goal of meeting or beating the performance of a specific benchmark.
  • Mutual funds have fees, which can be very low if the fund is passively managed and considerably higher if it is actively managed.

The Basics of Mutual Funds

Mutual funds pool money together from a group of investors and invest that capital into different securities such as stocks, bonds, or short-term securities. Each mutual fund has a different investment objective which drives the strategy and selection of investments within the fund. Each fund has a money manager responsible for the fund, and the manager's objective is to generate income for investors by investing portfolio assets and protecting the portfolio's value. Mutual funds can hold many different securities which makes them very attractive investment options.

Actively managed funds require a portfolio manager who constantly updates their holdings, while a passively managed fund's portfolio is built on a buy-and-hold strategy.

Advantages of Mutual Funds

There are several specific reasons investors turn to mutual funds instead of managing their own portfolio directly. The primary reasons why an individual may choose to buy mutual funds instead of individual stocks are diversification, convenience, and lower costs.

Diversification

Ask any investment professional, and they'll likely tell you that one of the most important ways to reduce your portfolio risk is through diversification. Instead of investing in just one company, industry, or investment vehicle, there's benefit to spreading your investments across different holdings to minimize potential losses. The less correlation your investments have, the lower the risk of them all dropping at the same time.

Many experts agree that the benefits of diversification are mostly realized when a portfolio holds stock in at least 20 different (and differing) companies. At that point, a large portion of the risk associated with investing has been diversified away. The remaining risk is deemed to be systematic risk that will impact any security you're holding.

Since most brokerage firms charge the same commission for one share or 5,000 shares, it can be difficult for an investor to buy into 20 different stocks. In addition, it's a delicate balance weighing the benefits of varying correlation coefficients with the long-term projected success of a company.

That's where mutual funds come into play. Mutual funds offer investors a great way to diversify their holdings instantly. Unlike individual stocks, investors can put a small amount of money into one or more funds and access a diverse pool of investment options as a single mutual fund may be comprised of dozens of different securities.

Mutual funds also invest in a variety of different sectors. Some of the biggest mutual funds invest in S&P 500 companies or large-cap stocks. Others may specifically target companies with smaller market capitalization or specific industries like technology, health care, or raw materials. Again, if you were to try to match this through individual stocks, you'd have to spend a lot of time selecting your investments.

Convenience

Another reason investors choose this investment option is the convenience of mutual funds. When deciding how to allocate the equity portion of your portfolio, you can defer that decision to an investing expert rather than buy individual shares yourself. Some investors find that buying a few shares of a mutual fund that meets their basic investment criteria is easier than researching companies to invest in and directly purchasing their stock. Investors use mutual funds when they prefer to leave the research and decision-making up to someone else.

This convenience translates into relying on a money manager to help determine your portfolio's asset allocation. People devote their entire careers to learning and understanding the stock market, so it's often more beneficial to rely on their expertise than attempt to learn the industry on your own.

Many mutual funds also offer investors a easy opportunity to buy into a specific industry or to buy stocks with a specific growth strategy. Here are several examples of the different types of easily accessible mutual funds:

  • Sector funds invest in companies within a specific industry or sector of the economy.
  • Growth funds focus on capital appreciation through a diversified portfolio of companies that have demonstrated above-average growth.
  • Value funds invest in companies that are undervalued and are normally held by long-term investors.
  • Index funds allow investors to track the overall market by constructing a portfolio that tries to match or track a market index.
  • Bond funds generate monthly income by investing in government and corporate bonds as well as other debt instruments.

Costs

The costs of frequent stock trades can add up quickly for individual investors. Gains made from the stock's price appreciation can be canceled out by the costs of completing a single sale of an investor's shares of a given company.

With a mutual fund, the cost of trading is spread over all investors in the fund. Therefore, the mutual fund capitalizes on economics of scale and often results in a lower cost per individual than if those individuals were to self-purchase the investments. Many full-service brokerage firms make their money off of these trading costs, and traders may find they are charged for every buy or sell order they place.

Most online brokers have mutual fund screeners on their sites to help you find the mutual funds that fit your portfolio. You can also search out funds that can be purchased without generating a transaction fee or funds that charge low management fees. Instead of paying fees every time you invest into a mutual fund, the mutual fund will charge an ongoing fee to cover the cost and labor of maintaining the fund.

Advisor Insight

Joe Allaria, CFP®
CarsonAllaria Wealth Management, Glen Carbon, IL

A mutual fund provides diversification through exposure to a multitude of stocks. The reason that owning shares in a mutual fund is recommended over owning a single stock is that an individual stock carries more risk than a mutual fund. This type of risk is known as unsystematic risk.

Unsystematic risk is risk that can be diversified against.

For example, by owning just one stock, you carry company risk that may not apply to other companies in the same sector of the market. What if the company's CEO and executive team leave unexpectedly? What if a natural disaster hits a manufacturing center slowing down production? What if earnings are down because of a defect in a product or a lawsuit? These are just a few examples of the types of things that could happen to one company but are not likely to happen to all companies at once.

There is also systematic risk, which is risk that you cannot diversify against. This is similar to market or volatility risk. You should understand there is risk associated with investing in the market. If the market declines in value as a whole, that is not something that can easily be diversified against.

Therefore, if you'd like to invest in individual stocks, I would recommend researching how you can compile your own basket of stocks so you don't own just one stock. Make sure you are sufficiently diversified between large and small companies, value and growth companies, domestic and international companies, and also between stocks and bonds—all according to your risk tolerance. This is where it might be helpful to seek out professional help when constructing these types of portfolios. Just know, though, that this type of research and portfolio construction and monitoring can take quite some time.

The alternative is to invest in a mutual fund for instant diversification. Of course, there is a list of things to be aware of when choosing mutual funds as well. Fees, investment philosophy, loads, and performance are just a few components to consider when evaluating mutual funds.

Things to Consider Before Investing in Mutual Funds

Before investing in mutual funds, consider the following:

  • Do you prefer to self-manage your own portfolio by picking your own stocks, or would you prefer deferring this responsibility to a financial expert?
  • What are your investment goals, and how will this impact the mutual fund you decide to invest in?
  • What fees are you willing to pay to have a mutual fund manage investments on your behalf?

Are Mutual Funds a Good Investment?

Mutual funds are a good investment for investors looking to diversify their portfolios. Instead of going all-in on one company or industry, a mutual fund invests in different securities to try and minimize your portfolio's risk.

What Are Some Disadvantages of Mutual Funds?

Mutual funds take control out of an investor's hands - instead of picking the companies you want to invest in, you're often limited to what a money manager thinks is best. There are also ongoing management fees associated with mutual funds that may be more expensive than brokerage companies offering low-cost or no-cost individual stock trades.

Are Mutual Funds Safe?

Like all other securities, mutual funds are investments that are subject to losses. However, the goal of a mutual fund is to reduce investment risk, so mutual funds can often be less risky than other types of investments due to its diversification.

Why Would Someone Choose a Mutual Fund Over a Stock? (2024)

FAQs

Why Would Someone Choose a Mutual Fund Over a Stock? ›

The primary reasons why an individual may choose to buy mutual funds instead of individual stocks are diversification, convenience, and lower costs.

Why buy mutual funds over common stocks? ›

Mutual funds are generally considered a safer investment than stocks because they offer built-in diversification—something that helps mitigate the risk and volatility in your portfolio.

What is the #1 reason investors prefer mutual funds for investing? ›

Mutual funds offer diversification or access to a wider variety of investments than an individual investor could afford to buy. Investing with a group offers economies of scale, decreasing your costs. Monthly contributions help your assets grow. Funds are more liquid because they tend to be less volatile.

Why do many people buy mutual funds instead of buying the stocks of individual companies? ›

Mutual funds offer convenience because investment decisions are left to a professional fund manager. Some investors prefer an index mutual fund, which tracks a market index and generally has lower fees compared with actively managed funds.

What are the advantages of a mutual fund? ›

Mutual funds offer several benefits to investors, including professional management, diversification, liquidity, low cost, tax benefits, affordability, safety, and transparency. However, investors need to consider several factors before investing in mutual funds.

Is it better to invest in mutual funds rather than buying stocks? ›

Mutual funds tend to carry less risk than investing solely in the stock market. This is because your portfolio will contain a range of assets, rather than a large share in a single company, for example.

What are the pros and cons of mutual funds? ›

One selling point is that they allow you to hold a variety of assets in a single fund. They also have the potential for higher-than-average returns. However, some mutual funds have steep fees and initial buy-ins. Your financial situation and investment style will determine if they're right for you.

Why do people prefer mutual funds? ›

Mutual funds are popular in part because they offer investors the opportunity to diversify, and therefore spread out their risk over a number of investments. Mutual funds appeal to people because they give average investors the opportunity to invest in professionally managed funds.

Why don't people invest in mutual funds? ›

As the funds are invested in market instruments, they carry certain stock market risks like volatility, fall in share prices etc., which deters us from investing in mutual funds. As we don't want to lose money, we often let it stagnate in our savings accounts.

Are mutual funds the best to invest in? ›

All investments carry some risk, but mutual funds are typically considered a safer investment than purchasing individual stocks. Since they hold many company stocks within one investment, they offer more diversification than owning one or two individual stocks.

Why do small investors use mutual funds? ›

Low costs. Because a mutual fund buys and sells large amounts of securities at a time, its transaction costs are typically lower than what you would pay as an individual investor.

What is the best mutual fund to invest in in 2024? ›

  • Fidelity 500 Index Fund. : Best overall.
  • Fidelity Large Cap Growth Index Fund. : Best for growth investors.
  • Fidelity Investment Grade Bond Fund. ...
  • Fidelity Total Bond Fund. ...
  • Vanguard Wellesley Income Fund Investor Shares. ...
  • Schwab Fundamental US Large Company Index Fund. ...
  • Schwab S&P 500 Index Fund. ...
  • Vanguard High-Yield Tax-Exempt Fund.
Mar 26, 2024

Are mutual funds safe for long term? ›

Mutual fund investments when used right can lead to good returns, keeping risk at a minimum, especially when compared with individual stocks or bonds. These are especially great for people who are not experts in stock market dynamics as these are run by experienced fund managers.

What are the five cons of a mutual fund? ›

Potential Cons
  • High fees. Mutual funds have expenses, typically ranging between 0.50% to 1%, which pay for management and other costs to operate the fund. ...
  • Market risk. Just as with stocks and bonds, mutual funds generally have market risk, meaning that prices can fluctuate up and down. ...
  • Manager risk. ...
  • Tax inefficiency.
Oct 6, 2023

What are the main disadvantages of mutual funds? ›

Disadvantages include high fees, tax inefficiency, poor trade execution, and the potential for management abuses.

What are the cons of investing in mutual funds? ›

Cons
  • Potential for loss: Mutual funds are not FDIC insured and may lose principal and fluctuate in value.
  • Cost: A mutual fund may incur sales charges either up-front or on the back end that are passed on to the investors. In addition, some mutual funds can have high management fees.
  • Tax implications:

What are the disadvantages in investing in common shares? ›

For common stock, when a company goes bankrupt, the common stockholders do not receive their share of the assets until after creditors, bondholders, and preferred shareholders. This makes common stock riskier than debt or preferred shares.

Do mutual funds beat the market? ›

Last year, 47% of actively managed open-end mutual funds and exchange-traded funds beat their benchmarks — a marked increase over the 43% hurdle rate in 2022. Morningstar refers...

What are the pros and cons of investing in stocks vs mutual funds? ›

To risk or not to
Mutual FundsIndividual Stocks
DiversifiedLess Diversified
Lower RiskHigher Risk
Ongoing Management FeesOne-Time Fee
Beginner FriendlyNot Beginner Friendly
2 more rows

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nicola Considine CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 6464

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nicola Considine CPA

Birthday: 1993-02-26

Address: 3809 Clinton Inlet, East Aleisha, UT 46318-2392

Phone: +2681424145499

Job: Government Technician

Hobby: Calligraphy, Lego building, Worldbuilding, Shooting, Bird watching, Shopping, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Nicola Considine CPA, I am a determined, witty, powerful, brainy, open, smiling, proud person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.